From 26ebb022e7e9f9ecfaeac68fe281ea8897a4f9be Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Jim Fenton Date: Wed, 27 Mar 2019 17:23:08 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] Moved old nomcom announcements to database and removed references to legacy website. Fixes #2686. Commit ready for merge. - Legacy-Id: 16108 --- .../0012_add_old_nomcom_announcements.py | 1307 +++++++++++++++++ ietf/templates/nomcom/announcements.html | 55 - 2 files changed, 1307 insertions(+), 55 deletions(-) create mode 100644 ietf/group/migrations/0012_add_old_nomcom_announcements.py diff --git a/ietf/group/migrations/0012_add_old_nomcom_announcements.py b/ietf/group/migrations/0012_add_old_nomcom_announcements.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c13ff9570 --- /dev/null +++ b/ietf/group/migrations/0012_add_old_nomcom_announcements.py @@ -0,0 +1,1307 @@ +# -*- coding: utf-8 -*- +# Generated by Django 1.11.20 on 2019-03-23 17:50 +from __future__ import unicode_literals + +from django.db import migrations + +from ietf.group.models import Group +from ietf.person.models import Person +from ietf.message.models import Message +from datetime import datetime + +def forward(apps, schema_editor): + + p=Person.objects.filter(name="Jim Fenton")[0] + +# Unfortunately, get_nomcom_by_year only works for 2013 and later, so we need to do things the hard way. + + n = Group.objects.filter(acronym="nomcom2002")[0] + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="nomcom call for volunteers", time=datetime(2002,7,30), + frm="Phil Roberts ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +This is the call for volunteers to participate in the 2002 IETF +Nominations Committee, the committee that will select this year's +nominees for the IAB and the IESG. Details about the Nominations +Committee process can be found in RFC 2727. + +The NomCom is the IETF's way of choosing its leadership. Typically, +half of the IAB and half of the IESG is selected each year. It is +possible that the NomCom will have to fill more or fewer slots than +this, due to the creation or elimination of positions by the IESG, +resignations, transfers, etc. IESG members whose terms are up are +Harald Alvestrand, IETF Chair; Scott Bradner, Transport; Randy Bush, +Operations & Management; Patrik Faltstrom, Applications; Thomas Narten, +Internet; Bill Fenner, Routing; and Jeff Schiller, Security. IAB +members whose terms are up are: Ran Atkinson, Rob Austein, Fred Baker, +Steve Deering, Sally Floyd, and Geoff Huston. + +For the NomCom to work as it should, the pool from which the volunteers +are chosen should be as large as possible. The more people who +volunteer, the better chance we have of choosing a random yet +representative cross section of the IETF population. Volunteering for +the NomCom is also a good way of serving the IETF community. So please +volunteer. + +NomCom members are barred from nomination during the year they serve, +even if they later resign. Therefore being selected for the NomCom +provides complete immunity against selection for the IAB or IESG during +that year. + +People who volunteer should be sure they can the afford the time, +several hours per week for the next 4-5 months. The task basically +involves the following activities: + + - Reading candidate's statements + - Participating in a weekly 2 hour conference call. + - Attending the IETF meetings held during the selection process. + - Doing several interviews. + - Speaking to IETF participants about the candidates, the job + requirements or the process. + +All NomCom deliberations and supporting information that relates to +specific nominees, candidates, and confirmed candidates are +confidential. The NomCom members will be exposed to confidential +information as a result of their deliberations, their interactions with +those they consult, and from those who provide requested supporting +information. All members are expected to handle this information in a +manner consistent with its sensitivity. + +To qualify as a volunteer, a person needs to have attended 2 out of the +last 3 IETF meetings. Anyone who meets this requirement is invited to +volunteer by emailing your name, telephone number(s), and email address +to proberts@megisto.com no later than September 6, 2002. Please put +"NOMCOM VOLUNTEER" in the subject line. + +Once the list closes, I'll provide the list to the IETF secretariat who +will verify the eligibility of the each of the volunteers (e.g. has +attended at least 2 of the last 3 IETFs). I will also ask them to +publish the list prior to verification for volunteers to confirm that I +actually received their email volunteering. This list will be +published at: http://www.ietf.org/nomcom/index.html + +We will then run the selection process and announce the results the +week of September 16, 2002. Ten (10) NomCom voting members will be +chosen from the pool of volunteers according to the procedure described +by Donald Eastlake in RFC 2777, "Publicly Verifiable Nomcom Random +Selection". The source of randomness will be based on the shares traded +number of 12 stocks selected by the NomCom chair. + +The official shares traded numbers (denoted in 000s) will be drawn from +the September 16, 2002 Wall Street Journal which reports the sales +figures from the previous trading day - September 13, 2002. If trading +in any of the stocks is suspended, then the shares traded will be +assumed to be 0. + +Please volunteer. + +Thank you, + +Phil Roberts <proberts@megisto.com> + +STOCKS USED IN THE NOMCOM SELECTION PROCESS: + +Martha Stewart Living (MSO) +Harley-Davidson (HDI) +Motorola (MOT) +Sony (SNE) +Metlife (MET) +Home Depot (HD) +Wrigely (WWY) +Granite Construction, Inc (GVA) +UPS (UPS) +Marriott International (MAR) +Quest Diagnostics (DGX) +Nordstrom (JWN) + +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="Selection of the Nominations Committee", time=datetime(2002,9,17), + frm="Phil Roberts ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +STOCKS USED IN THE NOMCOM SELECTION PROCESS, published result (in 100s), +number used as input (using 000s, rounded): + +Martha Stewart Living (MSO), 1562, 156, +Harley-Davidson (HDI), 12575, 1258, +Motorola (MOT), 86406, 8641, +Sony (SNE), 4061, 406, +Metlife (MET), 26384, 2638, +Home Depot (HD), 77244, 7724, +Wrigely (WWY), 2422, 242, +Granite Construction, Inc (GVA), 2134, 213, +UPS (UPS), 25343, 2534, +Marriott International (MAR), 20820, 2082, +Quest Diagnostics (DGX), 6471, 647, +Nordstrom (JWN), 3598, 360. + + +Output of selection run: +------------------------ + +Type size of pool: +(or 'exit' to exit) 146 +Type number of items to be selected: +(or 'exit' to exit) 10 +Approximately 49.8 bits of entropy needed. + +Type #1 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +156 +Type #2 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +1258 +Type #3 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +8641 +Type #4 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +406 +Type #5 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +2638 +Type #6 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +7724 +Type #7 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +242 +Type #8 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +213 +Type #9 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +2534 +Type #10 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +2082 +Type #11 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +647 +Type #12 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +360 +Type #13 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +Key is: + 156./1258./8641./406./2638./7724./242./213./2534./2082./647./360./ +index hex value of MD5 div selected + 1 E220923B36A9DC02559AD9D8A2A3788E 146 -> 23 <- + 2 4DA923C4AB28A35840731A3BC7FD6FED 145 -> 75 <- + 3 C15AC23F9DDA50A178749955C7DB4C53 144 -> 86 <- + 4 CF0F40F7AD1346B3DA357793950D7E01 143 -> 47 <- + 5 1FB9FDBD56707A1B656F095A3CF0ACEF 142 -> 74 <- + 6 C530071D6CD9E5FA83AA719D28C4013A 141 -> 127 <- + 7 9E9F928E84A3BF6DE15E336C9AF0EB14 140 -> 118 <- + 8 8668415B21041948BE0EE91A69724B4C 139 -> 15 <- + 9 26338CA7ED8FB029E20B1AD0DD34BEC4 138 -> 9 <- +10 369D706DC4051ADFD4259C287E78AAE7 137 -> 140 <- + +Done, type any character to exit. + +---------------------------------- +Nominations committee: + 23. Edward Lewis + 75. Alec Brusilovsky + 86. Michael Richardson + 47. Eva Jonsson + 74. Stephen Trowbridge +127. Frank Alfano +118. Thomas Kurien + 15. Dennis Beard + 9. Richard Draves +140. Eva Gustaffson + +""" + ) + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="Announcement of the Nominations Committee", time=datetime(2002,9,18), + frm="Phil Roberts ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +We have completed selection of the 2002 +Nominations committee. + +Please welcome the voting members of this +year's Nomcom: + +Edward Lewis +Alec Brusilovsky +Michael Richardson +Eva Jonsson +Stephen Trowbridge +Frank Alfano +Thomas Kurien +Dennis Beard +Richard Draves +Eva Gustafsson + +The non-voting members are: + +Phil Roberts (chair) +Allison Mankin (IETF liaison) +Eric Rescorla (IAB liaison) +Theodore Ts'o (previous nomcom chair) + +Information on this year's selection process is available at: + +""" + ) + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="Announcement of IESG and IAB Nominations Requests", time=datetime(2002,10,21), + frm="Phil Roberts ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +The 2002-2003 Nominations Committee is now +soliciting nominations for the open +slots on the IESG and IAB. + +Please take the time, even if it is +only a few moments, to send us your +thoughts. + +Members of the community are encouraged to +nominate candidates for any of the positions +which are up for re-filling: + +IESG Terms ending in March, 2003: +Harald Alvestrand IETF Chair +Scott Bradner Transport +Randy Bush Operations & Management +Patrik Faltstrom Applications +Thomas Narten Internet +Bill Fenner Routing +Jeff Schiller Security + +IAB Terms ending in March, 2003: +Ran Atkinson +Rob Austein +Fred Baker +Steve Deering +Sally Floyd +Geoff Huston + +Members of the community are encouraged to contact the nomcom confidentially +1) to nominate someone for any of these positions (please provide the email +address of any nominee), +2) to provide input relating to potential candidates, or +3) to provide comments regarding the past performance of incumbents. +All of this information will be considered during the deliberations of +the nominating committee and will be held in confidence by the nominating +committee. + +We emphasize that comments sent to the nominations committee will be kept +in confidence. As noted in RFC 2727 "all deliberations and supporting +information that relates to specific nominees, candidates, and confirmed +candidates are confidential." + +Self-nominations are accepted. The deadline for nominations is midnight +Friday, November 22, 2002. Early input is desirable so that candidates +may be interviewed during the Atlanta IETF meeting. + +The members of the NomCom can be contacted individually at the addresses +below or collectively at . Additionally, the members of +the NomCom will be identified at the IETF by a small orange dot +on their name tags. People are encouraged to take advantage of the +opportunity to talk to the members of the NomCom about nominations +and other issues related to the IAB and IESG membership. + +The 2002-2003 Nominations Committee +Edward Lewis +Alec Brusilovsky +Michael Richardson +Eva Jonsson +Stephen Trowbridge +Frank Alfano +Thomas Kurien +Dennis Beard +Richard Draves +Eva Gustafsson + +Non-voting members: +Phil Roberts (chair) +Allison Mankin (IESG liaison) +Eric Rescorla (IAB liaison) +Theodore Ts'o (previous nomcom chair) + +The role of non-voting members (from RFC 2727): + +"The nominations committee comprises at least a non-voting Chair, +10 voting volunteers, and 3 non-voting liaisons. The sitting IAB +and IESG members each appoint a non-voting liaison to the nominating +committee from their current membership who are not sitting in an +open position. The Chair of the prior year's nominating committee +also serves as a non-voting liaison. + +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="Announcement of IESG and IAB Nominations Requests", time=datetime(2002,11,05), + frm="Phil Roberts ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +The 2002-2003 Nominations Committee is now +soliciting nominations for the open +slots on the IESG and IAB. + +Please take the time, even if it is +only a few moments, to send us your +thoughts. + +Members of the community are encouraged to +nominate candidates for any of the positions +which are up for re-filling: + +IESG Terms ending in March, 2003: +Harald Alvestrand IETF Chair +Scott Bradner Transport +Randy Bush Operations & Management +Patrik Faltstrom Applications +Thomas Narten Internet +Bill Fenner Routing +Jeff Schiller Security + +IAB Terms ending in March, 2003: +Ran Atkinson +Rob Austein +Fred Baker +*Steve Deering +Sally Floyd +Geoff Huston + +*Please note that Steve Deering is on sabbatical and will not be a candidate +to return to the IAB. + +Members of the community are encouraged to contact the nomcom confidentially +1) to nominate someone for any of these positions (please provide the email +address of any nominee), +2) to provide input relating to potential candidates, or +3) to provide comments regarding the past performance of incumbents. +All of this information will be considered during the deliberations of +the nominating committee and will be held in confidence by the nominating +committee. + +We emphasize that comments sent to the nominations committee will be kept +in confidence. As noted in RFC 2727 "all deliberations and supporting +information that relates to specific nominees, candidates, and confirmed +candidates are confidential." + +Self-nominations are accepted. The deadline for nominations is midnight +Friday, November 22, 2002. Early input is desirable so that candidates +may be interviewed during the Atlanta IETF meeting. + +The members of the NomCom can be contacted individually at the addresses +below or collectively at nomcom@ietf.org. Additionally, the members of +the NomCom will be identified at the IETF by a small orange dot +on their name tags. People are encouraged to take advantage of the +opportunity to talk to the members of the NomCom about nominations +and other issues related to the IAB and IESG membership. + +The 2002-2003 Nominations Committee +Edward Lewis +Alec Brusilovsky +Michael Richardson +Eva Jonsson +Stephen Trowbridge +Frank Alfano +Thomas Kurien +Dennis Beard +Richard Draves +Eva Gustafsson + +Non-voting members: +Phil Roberts (chair) +Allison Mankin (IESG liaison) +Eric Rescorla (IAB liaison) +Theodore Ts'o (previous nomcom chair) + +The role of non-voting members (from RFC 2727): + +"The nominations committee comprises at least a non-voting Chair, +10 voting volunteers, and 3 non-voting liaisons. The sitting IAB +and IESG members each appoint a non-voting liaison to the nominating +committee from their current membership who are not sitting in an +open position. The Chair of the prior year's nominating committee +also serves as a non-voting liaison. +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="Announcement of IESG and IAB Nominations Requests", time=datetime(2002,11,12), + frm="Phil Roberts ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +The 2002-2003 Nominations Committee is now +soliciting nominations for the open +slots on the IESG and IAB. + +Please take the time, even if it is +only a few moments, to send us your +thoughts. + +Members of the community are encouraged to +nominate candidates for any of the positions +which are up for re-filling: + +IESG Terms ending in March, 2003: +Harald Alvestrand IETF Chair +Scott Bradner Transport +Randy Bush Operations & Management +Patrik Faltstrom Applications +Thomas Narten Internet +Bill Fenner Routing +Jeff Schiller Security + +IAB Terms ending in March, 2003: +Ran Atkinson +Rob Austein +Fred Baker +*Steve Deering +Sally Floyd +Geoff Huston + +*Please note that Steve Deering is on sabbatical and will not be a candidate +to return to the IAB. + +Members of the community are encouraged to contact the nomcom confidentially +1) to nominate someone for any of these positions (please provide the email +address of any nominee), +2) to provide input relating to potential candidates, or +3) to provide comments regarding the past performance of incumbents. +All of this information will be considered during the deliberations of +the nominating committee and will be held in confidence by the nominating +committee. + +We emphasize that comments sent to the nominations committee will be kept +in confidence. As noted in RFC 2727 "all deliberations and supporting +information that relates to specific nominees, candidates, and confirmed +candidates are confidential." + +Self-nominations are accepted. The deadline for nominations is midnight +Friday, November 22, 2002. Early input is desirable so that candidates +may be interviewed during the Atlanta IETF meeting. + +The members of the NomCom can be contacted individually at the addresses +below or collectively at nomcom@ietf.org. Additionally, the members of +the NomCom will be identified at the IETF by a small orange dot +on their name tags. People are encouraged to take advantage of the +opportunity to talk to the members of the NomCom about nominations +and other issues related to the IAB and IESG membership. + +The 2002-2003 Nominations Committee +Edward Lewis +Alec Brusilovsky +Michael Richardson +Eva Jonsson +Stephen Trowbridge +Frank Alfano +Thomas Kurien +Dennis Beard +Richard Draves +Eva Gustafsson + +Non-voting members: +Phil Roberts (chair) +Allison Mankin (IESG liaison) +Eric Rescorla (IAB liaison) +Theodore Ts'o (previous nomcom chair) + +The role of non-voting members (from RFC 2727): + +"The nominations committee comprises at least a non-voting Chair, +10 voting volunteers, and 3 non-voting liaisons. The sitting IAB +and IESG members each appoint a non-voting liaison to the nominating +committee from their current membership who are not sitting in an +open position. The Chair of the prior year's nominating committee +also serves as a non-voting liaison. +""" + ) + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="IETF Nomcom Announcement", time=datetime(2003,2,27), + frm="Phil Roberts ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +The nomcom is pleased to announce the results of the 2002-2003 +selection process. The IAB has approved the IESG candidates and +the ISOC has approved the IAB candidates. Please welcome them +in their roles. + + +The IESG selections are as follows: +Harald Alvestrand IETF Chair +Ted Hardie Applications +Thomas Narten Internet +Randy Bush Operations and Management +Bill Fenner Routing +Russ Housley Security +Jon Peterson Transport + +The IAB selections are as follows: +Bernard Aboba +Rob Austein +Sally Floyd +Jun-ichiro Itojun Hagino +Mark Handley +Geoff Huston + +And also Patrik Faltstrom has been selected to fill +the vacancy left by Ted Hardie, a one year term. + +Many people deserve to be thanked. First thanks are due to +all of those who volunteered to serve on the nomcom, and especially +to those who were randomly selected and served as voting members +of the nomcom. They contributed considerable time from their busy +schedules to participate in weekly calls, to conduct interviews, to +read questionnaires, and to make the selection of candidates. + +Thanks to those in the community who volunteered to serve on the IESG +and the IAB, both to those who were selected and those not chosen this +time around. Thanks very much for completing the questionnaires, the +follow-up questionnaires, and participating in interviews. + +Thanks are also due to the IETF as a whole for providing input to the +process through nominations, recommendations, and feedback on +potential candidates. + +The voting members of the nomcom are: +Edward Lewis +Alec Brusilovsky +Michael Richardson +Eva Jonsson +Stephen Trowbridge +Frank Alfano +Thomas Kurien +Dennis Beard +Richard Draves +Eva Gustafsson + +The nonvoting members are: +Phil Roberts - chair +Allison Mankin - IESG liaison +Eric Rescorla - IAB liaison +Ted Ts'o - past chair +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="Announcement of IESG and IAB Nominations Request", time=datetime(2003,6,11), + frm="Phil Roberts ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" + The nominations committee has received notice to fill the vacancy in the + Internet Area created with Erik Nordmark's departure. The nominations + committee is seeking nominees to fill the open position. The chosen + candidate + will serve out the rest of the current term, which ends in March 2004, + and the two year term following, according to the rules documented in RFC + 2727. + + Members of the community are encouraged to contact the nomcom confidentially + + 1) to nominate someone for this position (please provide the email + address of any nominee), or 2) to provide input relating to potential + candidates. + + All of this information will be considered during the deliberations of + the nominating committee and will be held in confidence by the nominating + committee. + + We emphasize that comments sent to the nominations committee will be kept + in confidence. As noted in RFC 2727 "all deliberations and supporting + information that relates to specific nominees, candidates, and confirmed + candidates are confidential." + + Self-nominations are accepted. The deadline for nominations is midnight + Tuesday, June 17, 2003. + + The members of the NomCom can be contacted individually at the addresses + below or collectively at . + + The 2002-2003 Nominations Committee + Edward Lewis + Alec Brusilovsky + Michael Richardson + Eva Jonsson + Stephen Trowbridge + Frank Alfano + Thomas Kurien + Dennis Beard + + Richard Draves + Eva Gustafsson + + Non-voting members: + Phil Roberts (chair) + Allison Mankin (IESG liaison) + Eric Rescorla (IAB liaison) + Theodore Ts'o (previous nomcom chair) + + The role of non-voting members (from RFC 2727): + + "The nominations committee comprises at least a non-voting Chair, + 10 voting volunteers, and 3 non-voting liaisons. The sitting IAB + and IESG members each appoint a non-voting liaison to the nominating + committee from their current membership who are not sitting in an + open position. The Chair of the prior year's nominating committee + also serves as a non-voting liaison. +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="Nomcom result announcement", time=datetime(2003,7,15), + frm="Phil Roberts ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" + The nomcom is pleased to announce that it has selected Margaret Wasserman + to fill the mid-term vacancy left by Erik Nordmark's resignation. + + Thanks are due again to many folks. First thanks are due to + all of those who volunteered to serve on the nomcom, and especially + to those who were randomly selected and served as voting members + of the nomcom. They contributed considerable time from their busy + schedules to participate in weekly calls, to conduct interviews, to + read questionnaires, and to make the selection of candidates. + + Thanks to those in the community who volunteered to serve on the IESG + and the IAB, both to those who were selected and those not chosen this + time around. Thanks very much for completing the questionnaires, the + follow-up questionnaires, and participating in interviews. + + Thanks are also due to the IETF as a whole for providing input to the + process through nominations, recommendations, and feedback on + potential candidates. + + The voting members of the nomcom are: + Edward Lewis + Alec Brusilovsky + Michael Richardson + Eva Jonsson + Stephen Trowbridge + Frank Alfano + Thomas Kurien + Dennis Beard + Richard Draves + Eva Gustafsson + + The nonvoting members are: + Phil Roberts - chair + Allison Mankin - IESG liaison + Eric Rescorla - IAB liaison + Ted Ts'o - past chair +""") + + n = Group.objects.filter(acronym="nomcom2003")[0] + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="IETF Nominations Committee Chair Announcement", time=datetime(2003,8,25), + frm="Lynn St. Amour", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" + One of the roles of the ISOC President is to appoint the IETF Nominations +Committee chair. This is done through consultation with the IETF and IAB Chairs +as well as the ISOC Executive Committee and it gives us great pleasure to announce +that Rich Draves has agreed to serve as the 2003 IETF Nominations Committee chair. +Rich can be reached at . + +A Call for Nominations for this committee will be sent shortly to the IETF +Announcement list; and a list of the IESG and IAB seats to be filled will also be +published shortly. Please give serious consideration to possible candidates for these +posts and in the interim, make your suggestions known to Rich, who will share them +with the committee when seated. + +This is an ambitious undertaking and it is important that the entire IETF community +assist as much as possible. Thank you in advance for your support and a sincere thank +you to Rich for agreeing to take on this important responsibility. + +Lynn St. Amour +President & CEO +The Internet Society +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="NomCom call for volunteers", time=datetime(2003,9,22), + frm="Richard Draves ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +This is the call for volunteers to participate in the 2003 IETF Nominations Committee, +the committee that will select this year's nominees for the IAB and the IESG. + +The NomCom is the IETF's way of choosing its leadership. Typically, half of the IAB +and half of the IESG is selected each year. It is possible that the NomCom will have +to fill more or fewer slots than this, due to the creation or elimination of positions +by the IESG, resignations, transfers, etc. IESG members whose terms are up are: +Ned Freed, Applications; Bert Wijnen, Operations and Management; Alex Zinin, +Routing; Steve Bellovin, Security; and Allison Mankin, Transport. +IAB members whose terms are up are: Leslie Daigle, Patrik Faltstrom, +Charlie Kaufman, James Kempf, Eric Rescorla, and Mike St. Johns. + +For the NomCom to work as it should, the pool from which the volunteers are chosen +should be as large as possible. The more people who volunteer, the better chance +we have of choosing a random yet representative cross section of the IETF population. +Volunteering for the NomCom is also a good way of serving the IETF community. +So please volunteer. + +NomCom members are barred from nomination during the year they serve, even if they +later resign. Therefore being selected for the NomCom provides complete immunity against +selection for the IAB or IESG during that year. + +People who volunteer should be sure they can the afford the time, several hours per week +for the next 4-5 months. The task basically involves the following activities: + +- Reading candidate's statements +- Participating in a weekly 2 hour conference call. +- Attending the IETF meetings held during the selection process. +- Doing several interviews. +- Speaking to IETF participants about the candidates, the job requirements, or the process. + +All NomCom deliberations and supporting information that relates to specific nominees, +candidates, and confirmed candidates are confidential. The NomCom members will be exposed +to confidential information as a result of their deliberations, their interactions with +those they consult, and from those who provide requested supporting information. +All members are expected to handle this information in a manner consistent with +its sensitivity. + +Details about the Nominations Committee process can be found in RFC 2727 and +draft-ietf-nomcom-rfc2727bis-07.txt. The 2003 NomCom will use RFC 2727 until 2727bis +is approved as an RFC, at which time we will switch (as much as possible) to 2727bis. + +To qualify as a volunteer, a person needs to have attended 2 out of the last 3 IETF meetings +(according to RFC 2727) or 3 out of the last 5 IETF meetings (according to 2727bis). +Anyone who meets either of these requirements is invited to volunteer by emailing your name, +telephone number(s), and email address to richdr@microsoft.com no later than noon in Seattle +on October 3, 2003. Please put "NOMCOM VOLUNTEER" in the subject line. + +I will check the eligibility of volunteers against both criteria and publish a up-to-date +list of verified volunteers at http://www.ietf.org/nomcom/index.html. On October 3, +I will decide whether to use the 2-of-3 or 3-of-5 rule, depending on whether 2727bis +has been approved by that date. This will result in a final list of volunteers. + +I will then run the selection process and announce the results on October 10, 2003. +Ten NomCom voting members will be chosen from the pool of volunteers according to the +procedure described by Donald Eastlake in RFC 2777, "Publicly Verifiable Nomcom Random +Selection". The source of randomness will be based on the shares-traded number of 12 stocks +selected by the NomCom chair. + +The official shares-traded numbers (denoted in 000s) will be drawn from the October 10, 2003 +Wall Street Journal which reports the sales figures from the previous trading day - October 9, +2003. If trading in any of the stocks is suspended, then the shares traded will be assumed +to be 0. + +The NomCom voting members will start their term on October 17, after the IETF community +has had a chance to review the random selection process. + +Please volunteer. + +Thank you, + +Rich Draves + +STOCKS USED IN THE NOMCOM SELECTION PROCESS: + +Motorola (MOT) +Lucent (LU) +Nortel (NT) +Liberty (L) +Pfizer (PFE) +General Electric (GE) +Nokia (NOK) +EMC Corp (EMC) +FTI Consulting (FCN) +Citigroup (C) +Corning (GLW) +Tyco International (TYC) +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="NomCom volunteer list", time=datetime(2003,10,6), + frm="Richard Draves ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +The final list of volunteers for the 2003 NomCom can be found at +http://www.ietf.org/nomcom. I would like to thank everyone who +volunteered. + +I will run the selection process and announce the results on October 10, +2003. Ten NomCom voting members will be chosen from the pool of +volunteers according to the procedure described by Donald Eastlake in +RFC 2777, "Publicly Verifiable Nomcom Random Selection". The source of +randomness will be based on the shares-traded number of the 12 stocks +specified below. + +At this time, 2727bis has not yet been approved as an RFC. Hence I will +use RFC 2727's eligibility criteria (attended 2 of the last 3 IETF +meetings) when performing the random selection. I will not check the +primary affiliation of the volunteers. If the RFC 2777 algorithm selects +an ineligible volunteer, I will repeat the method until I have ten +eligible and willing volunteers. + +The official shares-traded numbers (denoted in 000s) will be drawn from +the October 10, 2003 Wall Street Journal which reports the sales figures +from the previous trading day - October 9, 2003. If trading in any of +the stocks is suspended, then the shares traded will be assumed to be 0. + +The NomCom voting members will start their term on October 17, after the +IETF community has had a chance to review the random selection process. + +Thank you, + +Rich Draves + +STOCKS USED IN THE NOMCOM SELECTION PROCESS: + +Motorola (MOT) +Lucent (LU) +Nortel (NT) +Liberty (L) +Pfizer (PFE) +General Electric (GE) +Nokia (NOK) +EMC Corp (EMC) +FTI Consulting (FCN) +Citigroup (C) +Corning (GLW) +Tyco International (TYC) +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="Selection of the Nominations Committee", time=datetime(2003,10,10), + frm="Richard Draves ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +STOCKS USED IN THE NOMCOM SELECTION PROCESS, published result (in 100s), +number used as input (using 000s, rounded): + +Motorola (MOT) 143319 14332 +Lucent (LU) 636797 63680 +Nortel (NT) 266832 26683 +Liberty (L) 83877 8388 +Pfizer (PFE) 175698 17570 +General Electric (GE) 266052 26605 +Nokia (NOK) 137837 13784 +EMC Corp (EMC) 108120 10812 +FTI Consulting (FCN) 9765 977 +Citigroup (C) 145963 14596 +Corning (GLW) 116000 11600 +Tyco International (TYC) 107024 10702 + +Output of selection run: +------------------------ + +Type size of pool: +(or 'exit' to exit) 114 +Type number of items to be selected: +(or 'exit' to exit) 15 +Approximately 61.0 bits of entropy needed. + +Type #1 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +14332 +14332 +Type #2 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +63680 +63680 +Type #3 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +26683 +26683 +Type #4 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +8388 +8388 +Type #5 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +17570 +17570 +Type #6 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +26605 +26605 +Type #7 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +13784 +13784 +Type #8 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +10812 +10812 +Type #9 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +977 +977 +Type #10 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +14596 +14596 +Type #11 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +11600 +11600 +Type #12 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +10702 +10702 +Type #13 randomness or 'end' followed by new line. +Up to 16 integers or the word 'float' followed by up +to 16 x.y format reals. +end +Key is: +14332./63680./26683./8388./17570./26605./13784./10812./977./14596./11600./10702./ +index hex value of MD5 div selected + 1 F9B4D100A3CC11E9F996D3806ACF1E29 114 -> 56 <- + 2 319E2A14967C870FC89FDA06E21CB1A5 113 -> 44 <- + 3 2F0E1E14F6659112390388D06D5DC395 112 -> 88 <- + 4 D2D99A5EA018EF669293B370BE1F841A 111 -> 57 <- + 5 53AD4E59C1E64FBA45FD2686186DD855 110 -> 114 <- + 6 BBFF136BBE4E3580424039F6DB489300 109 -> 81 <- + 7 69748D37FC816759F04F6660672050E9 108 -> 55 <- + 8 CFE98B12654474DB49F0F224FD79AE0B 107 -> 84 <- + 9 0A7ADA8D4B330BDA96CE570E9ACACF72 106 -> 100 <- +10 B67F3A637817D2391A68FD0068D09A10 105 -> 82 <- +11 84F8A3A7EEC6C0EAB68233E3144CC892 104 -> 108 <- +12 C59B0A56531A8B9A280040E5FF9CF899 103 -> 47 <- +13 FB4AD25533FA8DC99ED7113A3A388BCD 102 -> 28 <- +14 D6CD94F1E92DAFE569FF0835063E5495 101 -> 105 <- +15 6C22311D8EB6F2298EB201DFFD1AFE22 100 -> 89 <- + +Done, type any character to exit. + +---------------------------------- +Nominations committee: +56. Kireeti Kompella +44. Abdul-jabbar Asiri +88. Jin Seek Choi +57. Richard Shockey +114. Ralph Droms +81. David E. Martin +55. NOT ELIGIBLE +84. Dan Forsberg +100. Ole J. Jacobsen +82. Basavaraj Patil +108. Andrew Thiessen +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="NomCom Selection", time=datetime(2003,10,10), + frm="Richard Draves ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +Please welcome the voting members of this year's nomcom: + +Kireeti Kompella +Abdul-jabbar Asiri +Jin Seek Choi +Richard Shockey +Ralph Droms +David E. Martin +Dan Forsberg +Ole J. Jacobsen +Basavaraj Patil +Andrew Thiessen + +The non-voting members are: + +Rich Draves (chair) +Phil Roberts (previous chair) +Bill Fenner (IESG liaison) + +The IAB has not yet selected its liaison - that should happen next week. + +The ISOC has appointed Brian Carpenter as its +liaison. Because 2727bis has not yet been approved, following the +procedures of RFC 2727 I will propose the addition of Brian as a +liaison, subject to the nomcom's approval. + +The nomcom's term will start on October 17, 2003, after the IETF +community has had a chance to review the selection process. + +Information on this year's selection process is available at +http://www.ietf.org/nomcom. I used the RFC 2727 eligibility rules. + +Thanks, +Rich +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="Call for Nominees", time=datetime(2003,10,17), + frm="Richard Draves ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +Please send the NomCom nominations for the open IESG +and IAB positions: + +IESG members whose terms are up are: +Ned Freed, Applications +Bert Wijnen, Operations and Management +Alex Zinin, Routing +Steve Bellovin, Security +Allison Mankin, Transport + +IAB members whose terms are up are: +Leslie Daigle +Patrik Faltstrom +Charlie Kaufman +James Kempf +Eric Rescorla +Mike St. Johns + +The nomination period will end at noon Pacific Time on Friday November 14. + +Any member of the IETF community may nominate any member of the IETF +community for any open position. Self-nominations are permitted. + +Please also send the NomCom your feedback on the past performance of the +incumbents. + +Thanks, +Rich +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="NomCom members", time=datetime(2003,10,24), + frm="Richard Draves ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +AB has appointed Geoff Huston as its non-voting liaison to the +nomcom. + +Following RFC 2727's provisions, the nomcom has voted to add Brian +Carpenter as a non-voting liaison with the ISOC board. + +To recap, the nomcom voting members are: + +Kireeti Kompella +Abdul-jabbar Asiri +Jin Seek Choi +Richard Shockey +Ralph Droms +David E. Martin +Dan Forsberg +Ole J. Jacobsen +Basavaraj Patil +Andrew Thiessen + +The non-voting members are: + +Rich Draves (chair) +Phil Roberts (previous chair) +Bill Fenner (IESG liaison) +Geoff Huston (IAB liaison) +Brian Carpenter (ISOC liaison) + +Thanks, +Rich +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="NomCom at IETF", time=datetime(2003,11,7), + frm="Richard Draves ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +Members of the nomcom at IETF will be happy to chat with you in person +about what the nomcom should look for in candidates for the IESG and +IAB, specific feedback about the incumbents or potential nominees, +suggestions for nominees, etc. + +Note that all such information and feedback is kept strictly +confidential within the nomcom. + +You can easily spot nomcom members because we will have orange dots on +our registration badges. Also, the nomcom will be holding "office +hours." You can drop by the "Directors Row 2" room, Tuesday through +Thursday, to find someone to chat with. Or you can always send email to +nomcom@ietf.org. + +Thanks, +Rich +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="NomCom News", time=datetime(2003,11,14), + frm="Richard Draves ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +Randy Bush has resigned from his position as O&M Area Director. Hence, +the nomcom will be filling Randy's position in addition to the +previously announced positions. + +Please submit nominations for Randy's O&M Area Director position to +nomcom@ietf.org. The deadline for these nominations is noon (Pacific +Time) on December 1. + +I am extending the deadline for nominations for the other positions to +noon (Pacific Time) on November 17. + +Any member of the IETF community may nominate any member of the IETF +community for any open position. Self-nominations are permitted. + +Please also send the NomCom your feedback on the past performance of the +incumbents, or feedback on potential nominees. + +All input to the nomcom will be kept strictly confidential. + +Thanks, +Rich +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="reminder - nominations to replace Randy Bush", time=datetime(2003,11,26), + frm="Richard Draves ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +At IETF Randy Bush resigned from his position as Operations & Management +Area Director for the IETF. This creates a mid-term vacancy that the +IETF NomCom needs to fill. Randy's replacement will have a one-year +term. + +Please submit nominations for Randy's O&M Area Director position to +nomcom@ietf.org. The deadline for these nominations is noon (Pacific +Time) on December 1. + +Any member of the IETF community may nominate any member of the IETF +community for any open position. Self-nominations are permitted. + +Please also send the NomCom your feedback on the past performance of the +incumbents, feedback on potential nominees, or your thoughts on what the +NomCom should keep in mind when considering candidates. + +All input to the nomcom will be kept strictly confidential. + +Thanks, +Rich +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="Randy Bush replacement schedule", time=datetime(2003,12,1), + frm="Richard Draves ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +For mid-term vacancies, RFC 2727 says "the selection and confirmation +process is expected to be completed within 1 month." However, there are +several factors that make a one-month schedule impractical in this +situation. + +1. Some nominees for Randy's O&M AD position are also under +consideration for other positions. +2. The two O&M ADs need to have complementary skills. +3. Candidates with operational experience & relationships are rare. +4. The Thanksgiving and Christmas holiday seasons. + +To have the best chance of producing a high-quality result, the NomCom +(after consulting with ISOC and the IAB as confirming body) has arrived +at the following schedule for filling Randy Bush's O&M AD position: + +1. Nominations due to NomCom by Dec 1, 2003. +2. NomCom produces confidential short-list by Dec 10. +3. NomCom makes decision by Dec 22. +4. NomCom notifies IAB on Jan 5, 2004. +5. IAB confirms (or rejects) by Jan 19. + +Thanks, +Rich +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="Randy Bush replacement", time=datetime(2004,1,14), + frm="Richard Draves ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +I am pleased to announce that the IAB has confirmed the NomCom's +selection of David Kessens for a one-year term as O&M Area Director, +filling the mid-term vacancy left by Randy Bush's resignation. + +Thanks, +Rich +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="NomCom results", time=datetime(2004,2,13), + frm="Richard Draves ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +I am pleased to announce the results of the 2003-2004 NomCom selection +process. The IAB has approved the IESG candidates and the ISOC board has +approved the IAB candidates. Please welcome them in their roles: + +The IESG selections are: +Scott Hollenbeck, Applications +Bert Wijnen, Operations and Management +Alex Zinin, Routing +Steve Bellovin, Security +Allison Mankin, Transport + +The IAB selections are: +Leslie Daigle +Patrik Faltstrom +Bob Hinden +Eric Rescorla +Pete Resnick +Jonathan Rosenberg + +Many people deserve to be thanked. First thanks are due to all of those +who volunteered to serve on the NomCom, and especially to those who were +randomly selected and served as voting members of the NomCom. They +contributed considerable time from their busy schedules to participate +in weekly calls, to conduct interviews, to read questionnaires, and to +make the selection of candidates. + +Thanks to those in the community who volunteered to serve on the IESG +and the IAB, both to those who were selected and those not chosen this +time around. Thanks very much for completing the questionnaires and +participating in interviews. + +Thanks are also due to the IETF as a whole for providing input to the +process through nominations, recommendations, and feedback on potential +candidates. + +The voting members of the nomcom are: +Kireeti Kompella +Abdul-jabbar Asiri +Jin Seek Choi +Richard Shockey +Ralph Droms +David Martin +Dan Forsberg +Ole Jacobsen +Basavaraj Patil +Andrew Thiessen + +The nonvoting members are: +Richard Draves, chair +Phil Roberts, past chair +Bill Fenner, IESG liaison +Geoff Huston, IAB liaison +Brian Carpenter, ISOC liaison + +Thanks, +Rich +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="call for Security AD nominations", time=datetime(2004,9,28), + frm="Richard Draves ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +Steve Bellovin has resigned from his position as Security Area Director, +effective the end of the November IETF meeting. The IESG has asked the +2003-2004 NomCom to fill the mid-term vacancy. Steve's replacement will +serve the remainder of Steve's two-year term. + +Please submit nominations for Steve's Security AD position to +nomcom03@ietf.org. The deadline for these nominations is noon (Pacific +Time) on October 11, 2004. Please include the nominee's email address or +other contact information. Feel free to comment on the nominee's +qualifications and the needs of the Security Area. + +Any member of the IETF community may nominate any member of the IETF +community. Self-nominations are permitted. + +Even if you do not wish to make a nomination, please send the NomCom any +input on the Security Area and/or potential nominees. + +All input to the NomCom will be kept strictly confidential. + +Thanks, +Rich +""") + + n.message_set.create(by=p, subject="Steve Bellovin replacement", time=datetime(2004,11,7), + frm="Richard Draves ", to="IETF Announcement list ", body=""" +I am pleased to announce that the IAB has confirmed the NomCom's +selection of Sam Hartman for a one-year term as Security Area Director, +filling the mid-term vacancy left by Steve Bellovin's resignation. + +I would like to thank everyone who volunteered their time and energy +for this process, including all the candidates, the members of the +community +who provided feedback, and the members of the nomcom. + +Thanks, +Rich +""") + + return + + +def reverse(apps, schema_editor): + n = Group.objects.filter(acronym="nomcom2002")[0] + + announcements = Message.objects.filter(related_groups=n) + announcements.delete() + + n = Group.objects.filter(acronym="nomcom2003")[0] + announcements = Message.objects.filter(related_groups=n) + announcements.delete() + + return + + +class Migration(migrations.Migration): + + dependencies = [ + ('group', '0011_auto_20190225_1302'), + ] + + operations = [ + migrations.RunPython(forward, reverse) + ] diff --git a/ietf/templates/nomcom/announcements.html b/ietf/templates/nomcom/announcements.html index 69e9c09ab..c47ede105 100644 --- a/ietf/templates/nomcom/announcements.html +++ b/ietf/templates/nomcom/announcements.html @@ -54,59 +54,6 @@ {% endfor %} - {# somebody ought to import these announcements in the DB instead of this mess #} -

Messages from 2003/2004

-

Committee chair: Rich Draves

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
DateSubject
August 25, 2003IETF Nominations Committee Chair Announcement
September 22, 2003NomCom call for volunteers
Selection of the Nominations Committee
October 06, 2004NomCom Volunteer List
October 10, 2003NomCom Selection
October 17, 2003Call for Nominees
October 24, 2003NomCom members
November 07, 2003NomCom at IETF
November 14, 2003NomCom News
November 26, 2003Reminder - nominations to replace Randy Bush
December 01, 2003Randy Bush replacement schedule
January 14, 2004Randy Bush replacement
February 13, 2004NomCom results
September 28, 2004Call for Security AD nominations
November 07, 2004Steve Bellovin replacement
- - -

Messages from 2002/2003

-

Committee chair: Phil Roberts

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
DateSubject
July 30, 2002First Call for Volunteers
Selection of the Nominations Committee
September 18, 2002Announcement of the Nominations Committee
October 21, 2002Announcement of IESG and IAB Nominations Requests
November 5, 2002Announcement of IESG and IAB Nominations Requests
November 12, 2002Announcement of IESG and IAB Nominations Requests
February 27, 2003IETF Nomcom Announcement
June 11, 2003Announcement of IESG and IAB Nominations Request
July 15, 2003Nomcom result announcement
- -

Historical information